Video quality showdown — Galaxy S10e versus iPhone XR Video high quality showdown — Galaxy S10e versus iPhone XR AppleInsider assessments the video recording aptitude of the brand new Samsung Galaxy S10e and the iPhone XR in a wide range of environments from slow-motion to stability.

iPhone XR (right) Galaxy S10e (left)
iPhone XR (proper) Galaxy S10e (left)

Each telephones will shoot primarily with a 12MP rear broad angle lens, every capturing video as much as 40Ok at 60 frames per second. Samsung has a couple of further options comparable to expanded zoom and Tremendous Slo-mo, although how they carry out is a bit questionable.

For our assessments, each telephones shot concurrently, side-by-side, within the inventory video apps with no submit correction executed for stability or colour. So what you see, is correct off the telephone.

Try all our pattern footage for your self in our hands-on video.


The comparability

The very first thing we examined was the steadiness of the telephones. Each telephones have optical picture stabilization (OIS), however the Samsung has an additional trick up its sleeve. In contrast side-by-side, they’re equally properly stabilized with each displaying a little bit of jiggle as we jogged down a flight of stairs.

We then turned on the S10e Tremendous secure mode and ran the steps once more. This time, the distinction was clear minimize. The Galaxy S10e had much more secure footage, blowing the iPhone away.

iPhone XR 1080p sample (left) and S10e (right)
iPhone XR 1080p pattern (left) and S10e (proper)

Following the steadiness take a look at, we needed to see how shortly every telephone adjusted to drastically completely different exposures. We aimed each telephones on the solar earlier than shortly directing them in the direction of a darkish, overcast wall.

As we moved from vibrant to darkish, the iPhone was a lot faster to regulate to the change in gentle. We additionally observed higher colour saturation on this state of affairs for the iPhone. The moss on the wall was extra vibrant whereas not being overly saturated and the Galaxy S10e was barely washed out.

Subsequent, we upped the decision on every telephone to 4K at 60 fps and took a tough shot that began on the vibrant solar, panned throughout a transferring waterfall, then again as much as some jagged rocks. On this take a look at, we needed to see how the colour stability modified, how shortly the telephones centered on the water and rocks whereas the digicam moved, and the way general sharp the footage was.

iPhone XR 4K sample (left) and S10e (right)
iPhone XR 4K pattern (left) and S10e (proper)

Samsung’s colours seemed nice, as did the iPhone’s, however the dynamic vary and distinction on the iPhone gained out when wanting on the particulars on the rock wall. On the waterfall, every telephone took a unique method. The S10e utilized a sharpening impact which made the water have extra outlined edges. The iPhone added slight movement blur that softened the look. Which is healthier is generally a matter of opinion.

To check focus, we held the telephones under a wall, and raised them as much as see how shortly they might alter and give attention to the transferring background. The Galaxy S10e gained out by about half a second over the iPhone.

Within the steady advertisements which might be performed on TV, Samsung likes to tout the slow-motion options of the newest telephones. We first filmed in normal slo-mo earlier than taking pictures the identical topic in Tremendous Slo-mo on the S10e.

In normal slo-mo, we noticed Samsung nonetheless sharpening the droplets of water, however we additionally noticed the rocks within the background shedding their sharpness. The iPhone, however, stored the sharpness within the rocks and softness within the water. The iPhone seems extra true to life.

S10e Super Slo-mo
S10e Tremendous Slo-mo

Tremendous Slo-mo on the s10e nonetheless has an too-tight crop issue which might actually restrict its purposes. High quality can also be nonetheless unhealthy, and the footage is dim, making it solely usable in vibrant, well-timed environments. Our waterfall topic appears significantly grainy in comparison with extra graphically-simple topics.

iPhone XR digital zoom max sample (left) and S10e (right)
iPhone XR digital zoom max pattern (left) and S10e (proper)

Every telephone has digital zoom, although the S10e has much more scope. It might probably zoom in virtually twice as a lot because the iPhone, however an identical scenario to Tremendous Slo-mo rears its head — footage is simply too poor to make it value it. Why zoom in a lot when it appears grainy, blurry, and washed out? There could also be some functions this could possibly be helpful, however it merely will not produce visually interesting photos.

Lastly, we put each telephones selfie cameras to check. The S10e wins in decision, with an 8MP digicam that may seize 4K footage. The iPhone XR is restricted to 7MP and 1080p 60fps. When filming our topic, we observed that similar to our photograph comparability, the pores and skin tone is a bit too gentle. We additionally took the chance to check the microphones. The iPhone was in a position to higher isolate our voice when standing in entrance of a billowing waterfall, however in much less noisy environments the Samsung stored the voice ranges louder.

Lights, cameras, motion!

Every telephone, more-so than in our photograph comparability, has their professionals and cons.

The iPhone actually nailed the white stability, publicity, and pores and skin tones. It additionally had the general better-looking footage.

Galaxy S10e
Galaxy S10e

Samsung actually did properly with the technical facets of the S10e, giving customers extra choices. The digital zoom and Tremendous Slo-mo options are spectacular in identify, however do not produce footage you’d truly wish to use. Samsung did nail our focus take a look at and did higher isolating audio.

The place to purchase

The Samsung Galaxy S10e might be ordered from Samsung instantly, in addition to at Samsung licensed sellers, comparable to B&H Photograph and, with costs beginning at $749.99.

In the meantime, the next carriers are additionally providing incentives on each Apple and Samsung units:

Service offers:


Related Posts

Leave a Reply